Indianapolis · Home sale
1160 Nantucket Dr in Cicero sells for $1.06 million
A single-family home at 1160 Nantucket Dr, Cicero sold for $1,059,000 on August 20, 2026. See the seller and buyer net sheets for this sale.
What would your home net? Get a free Hamilton County seller net sheet Agents: send a branded net sheet like this to your seller, free
- Sale price
- $1,059,000
- Sold
- August 20, 2026
- Property type
- Single-family home
- Living area
- 3,072 sq ft
- Price per sq ft
- $345
- Year built
- 1976
A single-family home at 1160 Nantucket Dr in Cicero sold for $1,059,000 on August 20, 2026, according to the sales disclosure form filed with the Hamilton County Assessor.
An aerial photo shows the parcel directly on a lake, with other houses around it.
The record lists Joseph R Headdy & Lory L Goebel and Lory L Goebel as the seller, and Coen, William Bradford & Ashley Jo and Ashley Jo Coen as the buyer.
The Assessor's records show 3,072 square feet of living area, a 1976 construction date and a 15,246-square-foot lot; the price works out to $345 per square foot. The market value on record is $611,600, and the sale price is 73% above that. Listing data shows 4 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms.
What this sale costs to close
What does closing cost at this price? Under Hamilton County custom the seller's larger charges are $3,066.60 for the owner's title insurance policy and $350 for the settlement / closing fee. With a 5% commission, the seller's estimated net is $997,193 before any mortgage payoff. A buyer putting 20% down would need about $226,308 at closing.
Run this net sheet with your numbers (free) See photos on Zillow
Source: Indiana Sales Disclosure Form data (DLGF, published by STATS Indiana), document C29-2026-0057203. Property details: Hamilton County Assessor. Net sheets are estimates from the NetSheet.org rules engine, not the parties' actual closing statements. Request a correction or removal.
