Shirley, New York transfer tax, closing costs and net sheet

Selling a $425,000 home in Shirley (about the median value there)? Expect about $24,835 in seller closing costs with a 5% commission. That is 5.8% of the price. That includes $1,700 of transfer tax.

See who pays what when you sell a home in Shirley. It is in Suffolk County, New York, and we apply the state and local rates for you.

Rates last checked September 2026. Reviewed by Harrison Farrell, founder. How we get these numbers

Free Shirley net sheet calculator

Free Shirley seller net sheet calculator

Change any number and the local costs update.

$
%
$
$
Real estate commission (5%)−$21,250
First mortgage payoff−$255,000
NY State real estate transfer tax−$1,700
Release / satisfaction recording−$60
Title insurance and settlement−$1,750
Other closing fees−$75
Estimated net to seller$145,165

Set for a July 1 closing. The full calculator adds your own date, credits, a PDF and email. Open the full net sheet
Median home value
$424,900
Transfer tax on $425,000
$1,700
Seller costs on $425,000
About $24,835
Median property tax bill
$9,187 a year
County
Suffolk County
Population
28,375

How much are seller closing costs in Shirley?

About $24,835 on a $425,000 sale, or 5.8% of the price. The 5% agent commission is $21,250 of that. Your share of the transfer tax is $1,700. Your attorney, the settlement fee, recording and other fees add about $1,885. Your loan payoff also comes out of the sale, but it is not a closing cost.

How much is the transfer tax in Shirley?

About $1,700 on a $425,000 sale. It is the NY State real estate transfer tax. By custom, the seller pays it. If the buyer borrows 80% of the price, the buyer also pays $2,690 in mortgage tax: Mortgage recording tax (Nassau/Suffolk/Putnam/Orange/Dutchess). The NY State mansion tax adds 1% of the whole price on sales over $1 million. The buyer usually pays it.

TaxRatePaid byOn $425,000
NY State real estate transfer tax$2.00 per $500Seller$1,700
Mortgage recording tax (Nassau/Suffolk/Putnam/Orange/Dutchess)0.80% borrower (1.05% total)Buyer$2,690
NY State mansion tax (residential $1M+)Starts over $1 million1% of price when $1,000,000 or moreBuyer$0
Single-family home, buyer financing 80% of the price. Who pays follows local custom and can be negotiated in the contract.
Sale priceSeller paysBuyer paysTotal
$250,000$1,000$0$1,000
$425,000 local median value$1,700$0$1,700
$500,000$2,000$0$2,000
$1,000,000$4,000$10,000$14,000
Transfer taxes on the deed, split by local custom.

What does a seller net on a typical Shirley home?

About $145,165, before property tax prorations. That is for a $425,000 sale, close to the area's median home value of $424,900, with a 5% commission and a $255,000 loan payoff. Homes in Shirley are worth less than the Suffolk County median of $578,400.

LineSeller
Sale price$425,000
First mortgage payoff−$255,000
Real estate commission (5%)−$21,250
NY State real estate transfer tax−$1,700
Settlement / closing fee−$250
Seller's attorney fee−$1,500
Release / satisfaction recording−$60
Wire / courier / payoff processing−$75
Estimated net before property tax prorations$145,165
Title and settlement fees are typical estimates, not quotes.

Run it with your own numbers.

How does Shirley compare with Suffolk County?

The median home value in Shirley is $424,900, 27% lower than the Suffolk County median of $578,400. On the same $425,000 sale, the transfer tax is the same as elsewhere in the county: $1,700.

FigureShirleySuffolk County
Median home value$424,900$578,400
Median property tax bill$9,187 a yearmore than $10,000 a year
Transfer tax on $425,000$1,700$1,700
Seller costs on $425,000About $24,835About $24,835
Population28,3751,530,146
Home value, tax bill and population: Census Bureau American Community Survey, 2020–2024. Costs from the rules engine, 5% commission.

Who pays closing costs in Shirley?

Here is who pays what in Shirley, by custom. The seller pays the agent commission and the transfer tax. The buyer pays for the owner's title policy, the lender's title policy and the fee to record the deed. Each side pays its own settlement fee. An attorney runs the closing. Each side normally has its own attorney. Shirley closings follow Suffolk County customs.

How are property taxes split when you sell in Shirley?

At closing, the year's tax bill is split by the day. Taxes here are paid in advance, so the buyer usually pays the seller back for the days after closing. Homeowners in the area pay a median property tax bill of $9,187 a year. That is about 2.16% of the median home value of $424,900. Town/county taxes billed Jan 1 for the calendar year and school taxes Sep 1 for Jul-Jun are paid in advance; seller is usually credited for prepaid taxes.

Rates verified 2026-09-30. Home value and tax bill: Census Bureau American Community Survey, 2020–2024. A net sheet is an estimate; final figures come from the title company.

Shirley seller net sheet questions

Who pays the transfer tax in Shirley, New York?

The seller, by custom. On a $425,000 sale the tax is $1,700. The contract can change who pays. The NY State mansion tax adds 1% of the whole price on sales over $1 million. The buyer usually pays it.

What are seller closing costs in Shirley without the commission?

About $3,585 on a $425,000 sale. With a 5% commission, the total is about $24,835, or 5.8% of the price. Your loan payoff and the property tax proration change what you take home.

Are homes in Shirley worth more than in the rest of Suffolk County?

No. The median home value is $424,900 in Shirley and $578,400 across Suffolk County (Census Bureau American Community Survey, 2020-2024).

What county is Shirley in?

It is in Suffolk County, New York. State and local rules set the transfer taxes and recording fees. Local custom decides who pays for title and closing. In Shirley, the buyer pays for the owner's title policy by custom. Each side pays its own settlement fee.

How much are property taxes in Shirley?

Homeowners in the area pay a median property tax bill of $9,187 a year. That is about 2.16% of the median home value of $424,900 (Census Bureau American Community Survey, 2020-2024).

Is the Shirley net sheet calculator free?

Yes. It is free to use, and you do not need an account to try it. It applies New York and local rates for you.

Make a free Shirley net sheet in minutes.

Free to use. No account needed to try it.