Cleveland · Home sale
31920 Creekside Dr in Pepper Pike sells for $1.39 million
A single-family home at 31920 Creekside Dr, Pepper Pike sold for $1,389,198 on September 25, 2026. See the seller and buyer net sheets for this sale.
- Sale price
- $1,389,198
- Sold
- September 25, 2026
- Property type
- Single-family home
- Living area
- 4,578 sq ft
- Price per sq ft
- $303
- Year built
- 1961
A single-family home at 31920 Creekside Dr in Pepper Pike sold for $1,389,198 on September 25, 2026—more than double its appraised value. According to the Cuyahoga County Fiscal Officer's transfer records, the sale price of $303 per square foot far exceeded the property's $585,000 market value on record.
Tonelli, Randall C Jr & Amanda S. sold the home to Brown, Joseph W. & Kristen P. The Cuyahoga County Fiscal Officer's records show the house contains 4,578 square feet of living area with 4 bedrooms and 4 bathrooms, according to listing data.
Built in 1961, the home sits on a 1.01-acre lot. An aerial photo shows trees covering much of the property, with other houses surrounding it.
The sale represents a significant jump over the property's assessed value, with the final price reaching 2.4 times the appraised amount.
What this sale costs to close
What does closing cost at this price? Under Cuyahoga County custom the seller's larger charges are $5,556.80 for the real property conveyance fee (state $1 + county permissive $3 per $1,000) and $2,642 for the owner's title insurance policy. With a 5% commission, the seller's estimated net is $1,295,844 before any mortgage payoff. A buyer putting 20% down would need about $291,699 at closing.
Source: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Officer, parcel transfer records (Cuyahoga County GIS), document 87225016-20260925. Property details: Cuyahoga County Fiscal Officer. Net sheets are estimates from the NetSheet.org rules engine, not the parties' actual closing statements. Request a correction or removal.
